The Shelley Hearing 7/8/2020




The Shelley Hearing was basically four hearings combined into two. The first three were combined at the request of Jonathan Huels, the Shelley family attorney. The last one was handled by itself. GPITA's function is either a fertilizer storage area or a chipping/composting area for Shelleys and is located further down the road on Jones Avenue.
I'm sure that those who weren't able to virtually attend the Code Enforcement for Shelley's Septic Tank are wondering how it went. Long story short, Orange County Code Enforcement prevailed with the Special Magistrate. Shelley's filed a suit against the County on June 24th, 2020. We have to wait to see if they will file an appeal regarding the Special Magistrate's decision. 

You can see the Orange County's PPT for the hearing here. This was obtained from Orange County Code Enforcement as it's public record.

You can see the Shelleys attorney's PPT for the hearing here. This was obtained from Orange County Code Enforcement as it's public record.
The last part of the hearing involved GPITA and there was another party involved in this hearing due to concerns about the GPITA property is affecting their property values. The other party's attorney, Gregory Lee, observed that "The odors are a byproduct of the illegal activity on their site." I wish we could afford him.
I believe that Special Magistrate was fair and decisive. When necessary she asked the right questions. While the smell wasn't part of the code violations discussed today, it was brought up at least six times. 

 After the hearing yesterday, I watched some of the afternoon proceedings which were much less involved than the Shelley case. It seemed ludicrous that mom and pop shops were cited for non-permitted promotional activities at $150 per day while Shelley's is not paying fines for code enforcement as far as I know.  

 Viewing the afternoon hearings also gave me a feel for the special magistrate. In my non-legal mindset view, she appeared to be fair, especially toward hardship cases.

Shelley's attorney intimated that someone is saying bad things about them on social media. As far as we are concerned, none of us has ever said that they want to close them down or made negative comments. In fact, every letter writer (writing for the public record for this hearing) I am aware of specifically said that we don't want to put them out of business.  We HAVE said that the business should have to follow the rules as everyone else does.

 So for now, we watch and wait,

Although the hearing wasn't about the smell, it was mentioned and got its own slide.

This slide was presented by the Shelley family attorney. He requested that the code enforcement proceedings be delayed until the lawsuit was resolved. He stated that it was not a delaying tactic, The requested action was denied.
Sending out a thank you to everyone who wrote letters to be admitted to the public record, sat in on the call, made comments during the hearing, and/or helped out in any way. We appreciate all of you.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Locations of Odor Complaints 3-03-2020

Image
The Daily Sludge Report Zero Days Without A Smell Report Check back for updates as reports come in It's 2:07 am on a clear and beautiful night . I took the dog out for a late walk, and there it was, waiting for me like a cat stalks a lizard... The stink. This morning was another day of stink . My phone was blowing up and I hadn't even opened my laptop. There'll be a lot to unpack today so hold on.  This was sent to Anuvia FB. "Hello. I live in Tangerine. March 2, 2020, and many other days in the last two years, I have taken my dogs out for a walk. As soon as we go out the door, we are hit by the strong smell of fertilizer and human waste smell. We often have to go back inside and wait until the smell goes away. Most of the time it just sits there like a heavy cloud. I am a captive in my own home, and my dogs have to suffer. This smell makes my throat burn and I start coughing. With the threat of coronavirus COVID-19 that specifically attacks the lungs, an...
Read more

Mount Dora's Wastewater Treatment Plant Smells.

Image
To: grusauskasj@cityofmountdora.com Letter 1 Dear Mr. Grusaukas,   I had to go to CVS in Mount Dora last night at 10:00 p.m.  I was traveling north on 441 and when I got to Stoneybrook Parkway there was a horrible sewage smell, even with the car windows up.  When I got to the top of the hill to the water plant the smell was enough to make you gag!  I continued to smell it all the way to Renningers.   45 minutes later when I was returning home and traveling south on 441 the stench was still there.  I cannot believe the poor residents of Stoneybrook are subjected to this.  What is wrong with the water plant?  I travel to Leesburg all the time and go right past their water plant and it never smells.  Mount Dora’s water plant is also an eyesore!  It is covered in black mold and looks disgusting!  Other towns have their water plants painted and they look neat and clean.   Mount Dora painted the stalls around the dumpsters in to...
Read more

Recording Odors and More: Advice for Sullivan Ranch and Stoneybrook Hills Residents

I haven't written about the Mount Dora City Council meeting on December 15th yet for several reasons. You can listen to a recording of the meeting here.  Although I was there, I spent all of the meeting in the hallway as the room was too crowded during a pandemic, so I didn't hear much of what was going on.  Although fixing the smell is important to me, my health and my significant other's health is more important.  It was clear to me that there was no regard for Covid-19 when the decision was made to hold the meeting in the City Council Meeting Room instead of the much larger Community Room. I don't know the room measurements but I believe that it was unsafe to be in. (I have a contract tracing certificate from Johns Hopkins.) You can calculate the number of safe minutes using the square footage, ceiling height, and the number of people present here.   I don't know how big the room is but I assumed it was 1,000 square feet with 12-foot ceilings. I don't know ho...
Read more